Waterproof Shadow Liner is rated 3.7692 out of 5 by 13.
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Very creamy, but not waterproof or smudge-proof... I got these in five colors:  blush, taupe, brown, chrome and black.Was excited to try them because I very often use eye liners on my waterline, so seeing that these were advertised as waterproof made me very happy;  I don't own any waterproof mineral liners.As you will see in the picture I included, these smudge very easily and are definitely not waterproof either, because I did the same test after splashing water on my arm and they smudge even easier that way.However, I do have to say that these eye liners are extremely creamy and very easy to apply, so I will definitely use all of them up and will repurchase the colors black and taupe.  Taupe looks amazing on the waterline because the color looks very natural but with a little extra glow.  It's usually very difficult to find a perfect nude color for the lower waterline, so this definitely does it for me.  And even though they don't pass the "waterproof test" this taupe did last surprisingly long on my waterline.The black liner is very black and the fact that it's so creamy and easy to apply is worth repurchasing it (for me at least).The chrome liner is not that pigmented;  I actually expected more color out of it, but still good for a smoky eye look.All of these blend out very well, by the way..."Blush" is kind of like a golden pink color, definitely darker than the taupe - the taupe liner is the most natural of them all.And the brown, again, is just as pigmented as the black, but it was a little too warm for me, so for those who don't like their browns too dark - perfect.Oh!  And they twist up, by the way which is super practical because you don't waste any product that way.Final verdict - I would definitely recommend these, but don't expect them to be waterproof.  If I had to purchase just one of them, I would go for "taupe".
Date published: 2014-07-12
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Bad color choice maybe. I bought the purple shadow liner (along with other products). They came in yesterday. I was so excited to swatch everything! When I swatched this, it doesn't even look purple. It looks charcoal/black. It only looks purple when in the light a certain way. Its good and creamy, but the color isn't what i was expecting.
Date published: 2014-07-09
Rated 2 out of 5 by from Ok I was really excited about the launch of these liners but they are not living up to my expectations.  I purchased the colors, navy, purple and lilac.As an eye shadow, I think these are a fail. They are a little waxy as opposed to creamy and take a little effort to build up pigmentation. They also blend out sort of splotchy.  I much prefer the L.A. colors, shadow sticks to these.  However, they work fine as eyeliners and that is how I will be using them.
Date published: 2014-07-07
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Great as a primer Im so happy with this shadow liner. I use it as a primer and it makes my eyeshadows more vibrant and last longer. Highly recommended taupe (inner highlighter) and the blush pinky one. 
Date published: 2014-07-06
Rated 5 out of 5 by from thick. soft. dense. Nice thick line. Just a Little sparkly. I don't even like sparkles but I love this liner.don't know how much is in it , but good price to start with.im old w/ wrinkles & this liner goes right over & under. Great.
Date published: 2014-06-26