Eyebrow Lifter & Filler is rated 3.8652 out of 5 by 230.
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Too soft, caked on and looked like a hot mess I bought this a few months back, and despite high and hopeful expectations, especially the "filler" side was far too soft and basically "caked" itself on, leaving me with greasy "sharpie-brows". It was horrible, and needless to say, it found its was to the trash quite quickly :(
Date published: 2014-10-09
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Love it! I absolutely love this filler! I am a natural blonde with blonde eyebrows and very pale skin- the light color works great to give my brows some definition! I lightly fill in my brows and then usually take a clean mascara brush to brush it out for a more natural look. I don't use the lifting side for my brows but I sometimes use it as a concealer, haha!
Date published: 2014-10-03
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Perfect I was really nervous about if this would work or not, I hate having fake looking brows. I have pale caramel colored skin on my face with dark brown almost black hair and it looks great. I got the dark pencil. I love that it's a fat pencil because it'll last forever! I use a small angled brush to apply it to my brows. Definitely recommend.
Date published: 2014-09-28
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Great concept! These eyebrow pencils go on smoothly. However, I wish it was all the filler color. Don't use the lifter end. Always sad when I get to the end.
Date published: 2014-09-23
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Spreads easy This is the very first time i've used this product, it's actually the first time i've used an eyebrow filler, and I can happily say that I really like it. You only need a little bit on the inner edge of your eyebrow, and it spreads easily to the other end. The only downfalls are that it's a little red tinted and stays almost [subtle] pasty feeling. I have medium-ash brown eyebrows that are widely spaced, so I figured the medium would work. It works alright, but like I said above, a little goes a long way. If you’re planning on buying this product, I would advice buying a lighter shade that your natural eyebrow color ( ie. Light for medium eyebrows, medium for dark eyebrows, dark for black eyebrows.) Overall I’m satisfied with my purchase :)
Date published: 2014-08-16
Rated 3 out of 5 by from This product is really creamy. I bought a shade that was too dark for me so I don't want to say all bad things about it because I know some of it has to do with the color. You do not need a lot when using this. Use a real little and try to blend it out or else your eye brows look really fake. I think that if this was a thinner pencil it would be a lot better product. The lifter is really great. I use that all the time before I put a lighter shade of eye shadow underneath my brow.
Date published: 2014-08-04
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Wonderful! I dye my hair slightly darker than its natural color. My eyebrows were always a struggle until I found this stuff! I use everyday and absolutely love it. I use the light (its actually not very light at all) and matches my dark brown hair wonderfully.
Date published: 2014-07-17
Rated 2 out of 5 by from :( its too dark for me. But the lifter is wonderfu It is sort hard to find a natural looking blonde eyebrow color. Sadly the “light” isn’t light enough for me. It’s really actually very dark. The lifter is fantastic!  It’s every bit as good as Benefit High Brow (only it’s like the soft pink one…not the shimmery ones) Since I love the lifter so much I guess I will keep purchasing it. I just wish, wish, wish they would give some of us blondes some love and come out with a lighter shade in this. 
Date published: 2014-07-16
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Easy to use I ordered this product but didn't know if I would like it--Pleasantly surprised, easy to use, looks natural, lasts.  The price is right too!
Date published: 2014-07-03
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Works great, but Even Light is too dark! I've had this for months and I love the idea. I have the ivory/light. I'm blond and fair skinned. The ivory part (highlighter) is a perfect match. No problems there. But the light is actually too dark. I have fairly dark blond hair so I didn't think I would have this problem. But whenever I use it, it makes my eyebrows look too dark for my hair/face. Going to have to abandon it because it just looks unnatural. It's so easy to use though. I wish it came in a lighter shade! :(
Date published: 2014-06-28
Rated 5 out of 5 by from My new favorite product. This pencil is great. It's amazing and I love it. Both sides are very creamy. The filler works well is you use a very light hand when applying. Now, forget about this being an eyebrow pencil. THIS MAKES THE BEST CONCEALER/ CONTOUR EVER. The ivory side blends in perfectly with my skin. I apply it under my eyes and my dark circles have never been so well concealed! The filler side, mine is in dark, can be used on the sides of the nose and under the cheek bones to contour. It blends like a dream. Everything comes out to a natural finish. My makeup for the last few days has looked incredible the last few days since I got this. In my next elf order, I will be getting more of these pencils<3 Versatile may not be enough to begin describing this product.
Date published: 2014-06-02
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Looks great, not good for oily skin I was always used to filling in my brows with an ordinary pencil. I wanted to use a highlighter so I came across this product. It makes my eybrows look FLAWLESS! I get sooo many compliments on it. The downside is that, I have very oily skin. Because this pencil has a "waxy" substance to it, it will make your eyebrows VERY shiny and oily as the day goes on. I use the darkest color (I am of Asian decent and have dark eyebrows and medium tone skin) but you must use a good angled brow brush with it. Don't try to just draw them on! I wish ELF made just the highligher pencil and/or change the consistency so it doesn't make my brows so greasy!!!
Date published: 2014-05-21
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Not perfect, but still the best I've found I really like this product. I'm Asian, so I have weird patchy eyebrows. I need to draw on a bit of eyebrow where there is not a single hair. This pencil (I have the darkest one) is very highly pigmented, and the pencil is nice and soft so it goes on very smoothly. I do apply with a small, dense brush. I can't imagine anyone successfully using this giant crayon by just drawing directly on their face. Because it's soft and smooth, it can smudge a bit over the day, but I have exceptionally oily skin, so most people won't have that problem. I don't really use the light end. I have, and it really does make my brows look more defined, but it's just not really the look I'm after. I'm happier with a swipe of highlighter up there. So, in a perfect world, it wouldn't move on my skin at all, but so far, I haven't found anything else that stays any better than this, so I suppose it's me and not the pencil.
Date published: 2014-04-12
Rated 5 out of 5 by from my HG Eyebrow tool I used to over obsessess about my MAC Impeccable pencil in Taupe. Went through about 4 or 5 of those, until it got discontinued. My search got me to try this product in Medium (WOW, it's a DUPE). I also bought the eyebrow kit, but that takes time for me to get my eyebrows the way I want and I don't have time for that in the morning. This is perfect, like everyone has already said. it's Blendable, Perfect match, looks realistic, the highlighter is Amazing. Did I mention I love this thing ????
Date published: 2014-04-03
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Great color and value! I got this in my first order from E.L.F (it was a big one) and I really love this pencil! Very blendable and I use the highlight side for everything! The highlight is great on your lower lash line to make your eyes pop and seem bigger! I wouldn't say its comparable to my higher end pencil (Anastasia of Beverly Hills) but it is a perfect low cost option! The only cons are you have to use a really light hand when applying but it blends really well and the caps keep falling off both sides of the pencil so it gets smudged In my bag. Nothing I can't live with though!
Date published: 2014-03-17
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Woooow Words can not describe the love I have for this product. I have it in the darkest color it comes in. So perfect for those who prefer to pencil in thicker lashes. The product itself is so soft on the skin and ridiculously blendable. And the ivory end is so perfect for faking higher arches. Would not suggest if you lean more towards thin brows.
Date published: 2014-03-14
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Use a VERY light hand If you use a light hand and lighten it will look pretty natural, but if not you look like a drag queen with cartoon brows.
Date published: 2014-03-06
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Anastasia Beverly Hills brow wiz drugstore dupe!!! I love this pencil!!!! I am so please to find such a close dupe to my brow wiz, for a fraction of the price! It's cool ashy tones are natural looking, as suppose to most brow products that are more warm reddish. The white side is perfect for under the brow bone, on the inner corner, the waterline and even the Cupid's bow 
Date published: 2014-02-22
Rated 1 out of 5 by from makes your eyesbrows nasty i bought this during the 50% off site wide sale and was so excited for it. it just came in today and as i apply it on my eye brows it makes it looks like i have poop on my eyebrows. its kindda sticky and hard to work with! 
Date published: 2014-02-20
Rated 5 out of 5 by from BEST EYEBROW DEFINER AND FILLER EVER I bought this a couple weeks ago and the color of the filler is amazing, and the lifter part makes my eyebrows and the color and shape of my eyebrows pop its so amazing i suggest this to everyone!
Date published: 2014-02-18
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Easy to use Easy to use and good pigmentation.  Use a light hand when applying because otherwise it'll go on too dark.  Also I use an eyebrow brush after applying to make it more natural.  I'm very happy with this item overall and the lifter does a great job.  I like that the color goes on easily, with that said it can be just as easy to smudge.  I recommend "sealing" the color with some powder (foundation or translucent) for it to last all day.  That's how I use it and I have very oily skin.
Date published: 2014-02-07
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Not what I expected, but does hold up I bought one and I got one in my beauty bundle. I can say the highlight side I love very much. It goes on well and blends perfectly. The dark side I hate. It comes off in a sticky way, if I sweat a little bit or pass my hand over my eye brows it smears and rubs off. Its not that bad but its not what I'm used to. Once I am done with these I don't think Ill buy anymore.
Date published: 2014-02-03
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Best eyebrow filler yet! One of the best elf purchases I have made! I made the mistake of over plucking and waxing my brows for many years. They are quite sparse. I have used many brands of pencils, liquids, powders. By far this ie the easiest to use, creamy and long lasting. I apply it on my brows at 530 or  6am everyday. After my ten or twelve hour shift, my brows are still full. This product if amazing!!!
Date published: 2014-02-02
Rated 2 out of 5 by from Too Dark! I got this product in medium and it looked—and felt—really heavy! I have thick-ish brows and this brow pencil made them look huge and much too dark. This product is VERY heavy and if you're going for a natural look I wouldn't recommend it.
Date published: 2014-01-24
Rated 4 out of 5 by from So far so good I haven't master the technique of the perfect brow so please take into accountPros:the lightest one works best with my eyebrowEasy to apply Perfect for beginners ConsWaxy the pencil is very waxy and easily smudges When sharpening the pencil easily clogs the sharpener Overall I will continue using 
Date published: 2014-01-14
Rated 5 out of 5 by from WONDERFUL My eyebrows are SUPER sparse and I've tried many different  eyebrow filler pencils/shadows/etc. over the years from all price ranges, and this is by far the easiest to use, the most convenient because it has a sharpener and the lifter attached to it, and the most economically priced. Also, the shade I use (dark) matches perfectly with my hair color, as most other brands don't have a color that is this particular shade of brown! Good for beginners all the way to people who have been turning out fierce eyebrows for years.
Date published: 2014-01-12
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Deff Beginner Friendly I don't really fill in my brows, but I dyed my hair brown and I have light eyebrows so I needed something that looked natural and was easy for a first-timer to use. It's great, the colors are universal, it all depends on how much you apply and how you blend it. The lifter is AMAZING. It's thick and creamy, it makes my eyebrows look on point! Love it.
Date published: 2013-12-27
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Great product I almost didn't give this a try because the second darkest shade was out of stock and I thought the lightest color would be too light, but it was inexpensive and since I recently went back to my natural hair color (blonde) I figured I'd give it a try, I am so glad I did. If I went with the medium dark color it would have been way too dark for both my skin tone (fair) and my hair color. I've seen people rave in reviews about the lift- it doesn't do much for me. The filler is very soft, takes a very light touch to get the shade right which is a very welcome change from some of the fillers I've used that dry out too fast and therefore require a harder push.It does wear off, but touch ups are easy and quick which makes it's size very convenient for travel.
Date published: 2013-12-27
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Love it Sooo I have the eyebrow kit and I thought that was the end all be all...but this takes the cake! I love it and it gives me better control than the little brush in the eyebrow kit. Everyone keeps asking me if I just got my eyebrows done...and I havent ..its been weeks! Will buy again...when its back in stock.
Date published: 2013-12-24
Rated 5 out of 5 by from The only brow pencil that works for me!! I shave my eyebrows off completely...for different reasons... I started doing it 6ish years ago but i HATE my real eyebrows. For years i have tried so many different brow pencils and they either dont give off enough product, color, they dont stay, dont go over foundation, too thin, consistency is too hard...etc. but THIS is PERFECTION! I use it everyday! Its so soft so you're not pushing down and scraping it on your brow area! I can only say  good things about this product! 
Date published: 2013-12-20