Brightening Eye Liner is rated 3.5406 out of 5 by 616.
Rated 4 out of 5 by from I like it, but it wears off my waterline pretty quickly. Works great on my eyelids, though!
Date published: 2014-01-14
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Eh... I bought this for myself when I did a big order from E.L.F. and I was very disappointed. It feels like someone is trying to pull you eyelid off when trying to apply and it doesn't even look like anything is on. Other E.L.F. products are great but not this one.
Date published: 2014-02-06
Rated 5 out of 5 by from great I have this in coffee. I use it daily. Its smooth and easy to use, its a great little pencil with good pigmentation and great for an understated look.
Date published: 2014-02-20
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Love! I got the gold one a few days ago and I really love it! It glides on really well and doesnt hurt the eye at all! It would be nice if they had silver though! Really really worth the price!
Date published: 2014-02-20
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Love it! I bought this a few weeks ago in the colour coffee and I love it! It glides on smooth with good pigment. I use it when I don't want to go too dark with black liner
Date published: 2013-12-07
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Love this! I bought this and its one of my fave eyeliners by far! I love this so much!
Date published: 2013-12-01
Rated 2 out of 5 by from - not what expected at all!- hi. i got this. mini one. doesn't show! and it just looks smudged in a bad way! not what i taught. i wasted money and time and effort! it just goes in my basket of unused cosmetics on my dresser! what a waste. sorry. FROM THE PICTURE I LIKE THE LOOK OF IT -
Date published: 2014-02-09
Rated 3 out of 5 by from It's okay I just tried this eyeliner today. When I first put it on, it looked great. Nice dark color, and went on very smoothly. I had used eyeshadow primer and then eyeshadow, then used the eyeliner over the top of everything. The color faded very quickly on my top lid, like within ten minutes. It is still there, just not the gorgeous black it was when I first applied. It still looks good on my bottom lid though, so maybe it just isn't good to use over eyeshadow.
Date published: 2013-11-19
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Wonderful I purchased the plum and absolutely love it. I will definitely be buying it again, and going to try some other colors. The pigmentation is great, goes on so smooth, and it's been long lasting for me.
Date published: 2013-11-07
Rated 2 out of 5 by from Okay... I bought this eyeliner in ash and midnight, and I wasn't really satified.  They both had terrible pigmentation, wasn't smooth and was really dry.  I tried to love these but I just couldn't :(
Date published: 2014-01-29
Rated 1 out of 5 by from terrible colour payoff and does not last long! I have this in the colour black and it does not come off black on my eyelids. It is very drying and I have to really press down hard in order to get colour out of this pencil. It smudges like crazy as well, and although I have oily eyelids, I don't think it would last long on non-oily eyelids either as it has faded on my waterline as well. 
Date published: 2014-01-29
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Skip this eye liner Purchased this in black, grey, and brown. Wears off in less than an hour.
Date published: 2014-01-29
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Hit And Miss I've had this in Plum for a while now. i felt confident to get another shade. But the second one i got, in midnight, isn't anywhere near a soft and creamy as Plum. I was very dissapointed
Date published: 2013-11-20
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Meh I'm not as in love with this product as I am with elf's liquid liners. I got it as a gift in Plum. I'm not a huge pencil fan either. It's just ok. Doesn't fade, but it smudges really easily. Hard to beat a buck though!
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Worst Eyeliner I've Used I bought this on a whim because it came with a sharpener and I needed one, but I thought I would be getting a decent black eyeliner as well. I was wrong. It did not go on well, the tip breaking almost immediately. After I sharpened it and continued, it still didn't go on as easily as other products I've used, and as it went on it looked clumpy and uneven. Once I did get it on, it smudged almost immediately, but that wasn't a huge problem because it also faded extremely quickly and what little was still left easy came off with water. The single most disappointing make up purchase I've made.
Date published: 2014-01-29
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Worked For Me I was afraid I wasn't going to like these liners after reading the reviews on here but I actually really like the 2 that I got. They go on very smooth and have great color to them. I have extremely oily skin and other liners that I've used have smeared or faded within an hour after applying them. These stayed on very well there was hardly any smearing. I liked them and would definitely buy them again.
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 2 out of 5 by from nice but..... I absolutly love elf but was dissapointed by the eyeliner they fade very quickly.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Great Eyeliner I use this eyeliner pencil almost everyday it works great for what I use it for. It goes on smoothly and isn't heavy. The only bad thing about this eyeliner is that it can be just a little irritating making the corners of my eyes sting just slightly which isn't that big of a deal since I can fix it by just removing it.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 1 out of 5 by from You get what you paid for This product is not very good. I got "Black" and it was very difficult to apply. it also only about 5 minutes later began to smear and fade. Do not buy.
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 3 out of 5 by from not that great These eyeliners are just okay. They would go on easily enough, but the color easily rubbs off, smudges and fades. Also, it just never seemed to deposit a dark enough color, especially the black one. There are much better eyeliners out there.
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Pretty decent I use the product to line my top lashes, like normal. I love eyeliner, I want all the eyeliners I can get my fingers on. This one was.. Satisfactory. Its not for waterlining, as you do gotta be a little hard on it for it to work (I have this neato idea where I heat it up between my hands a little. Makes it a little less pigmented, but makes it easier to use), and can cause eye irritation. The sharpener... Gosh. I love that thing. Above all it was alright.
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 4 out of 5 by from The Sharpener I got this a few years ago and from what I remember the eyeliner is just whatever and not that great, however, the sharpener is the best. I forget sometimes, but I've been using this same sharpener for about 3 years and it is the greatest one I've ever used.
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 2 out of 5 by from I want MORE I loved that this came with its own sharpener. I swatched it on my & it was pretty pigmented. When it came down to applying it to my eyes, it had to go over it a few times before it came out to the nice plum color I wanted. The next time I used it, I ran the tip through a lighter for less than a second to help it be more malleable & opaque. When I tried to apply it, nothing showed up. That was weird so I tried again on the other eye. Still, nothing. Just for the benefit of the doubt, I tried one more time & the color popped right off the pencil. I gave up on it & I've yet to try it again
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Grab and Go I mainly use the coffee and black either for my brows or for my eye liner. But this product does smudge but to provent that I use a powder to set the liner in. But this is a very versatile product from brows,eye liner to eye shadow. So to eyeone that say it fades which it does; just set with a powder and you'll have all day/night wear!
Date published: 2013-11-28
Rated 3 out of 5 by from An okay eyeliner If you're on a budget and don't have oily eyelids, this eyeliner is perfect for you. In all honesty, I don't really like to use this eyeliner if I know I'll be out for more than 5 hours. I have very oily eyelids so maybe it's not the eyeliner's complete fault that it fades especially around under my eyes and making me look like a raccoon. I'd also have to reapply more when it fades, usually ever hour. Even when I put eyeshadow on before applying this eyeliner, it still fades but again, I do have very oily eyelids. Nowadays I put this on before applying liquid eyeliner over it, and that's the only time this eyeliner doesn't fade. At least this eyeliner is very easy to use so it's up to you if you want to use this eyeliner or not.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Great Deal for The Price This eyeliner in black is my everyday eyeliner. It's very creamy and easy to apply. I usually apply it to the outer half of my lower eyelid and waterline. It does fade to a dark grey after a few hours, but most eyeliners tend to fade on me and this one outlasts most of them. Really great for a smokey eye look since it blends beautifully. This is also a con, since it does smudge pretty easily. It is completely worth the price.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 2 out of 5 by from dont buy I love how it was easy to apply, didn't have trouble, but it smudge in 4 hours, an eyeliner that smudges is a useless eyeliner.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 3 out of 5 by from It's just alright. I always use pencil eyeliners for my waterline. I gave this a try in the color black. It was just an ok eyeliner. Not bad, not good. The color is ok, and the application is smooth, but if you do use this by morning, it will smudge and fade by mid-day.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Good for someone in a budget but... It's a good eye liner if you are in a hurry or to add a little pop in your eyes... But they fade in 8 hours... I use the coffee color and it's nice for people who uses minimal make up.
Date published: 2013-11-27
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Love It! I love this thing, it is awesome, it glides on effortlessly. I applied it on the morning and it stayed on all day, I also have an oily face. I haven't tried it on my waterline but I don't want to since you need the best of luck to find one that won't fade, considering your waterline is always wet, hence the name WATERline.
Date published: 2013-11-27